Document information

Physical location:

RB MSS M4, Library, Royal Botanic Gardens Melbourne. 67.11.17

Plant names

Preferred Citation:

George Bentham to Ferdinand von Mueller, 1867-11-17. R.W. Home, Thomas A. Darragh, A.M. Lucas, Sara Maroske, D.M. Sinkora, J.H. Voigt and Monika Wells (eds), Correspondence of Ferdinand von Mueller, <https://vmcp.rbg.vic.gov.au/id/67-11-17>, accessed June 19, 2025

25, WILTON PLACE, S.W.
Nov 17/67
1
MS annotation at top of letter in M's hand: 'Niemeyera'.
My dear Sir
I was much pleased to learn by your last letter that you found yourself much better for your visit to Queens Cliff Mr Wilson
2
Edward Wilson?
whom I met the other day at a dinner party tells me that he also has heard better accounts of you — I trust that you have now quite recovered your usual health and that you will not overwork yourself.
The whole of the plants you announce as having sent off have arrived safely, those per Great Britain first and per Sussex a few days after. I hope that the remainder of
Monopetalae

Search for Monopetalae in

may be on their way ere this reaches you
In one of your letters you speak of several of Drummonds nos not being quoted by me,
3
M to G. Bentham, 26 March 1867 (in this edition as 67-03-26a).
the reason is that these numbers are very irregularly preserved in the Hookerian herbarium which has the most complete set. The first collection was distributed in the first instance as sent over here without numbers, of this I see numerous specimens from the Hookerian, my own, Lindley's and other herbaria, corresponding specimens were afterwards sent with numbers which were not regularly entered in the herbaria which had them without numbers — then came successively the 2d 3d 4th 5th and 6th collections and various supplements all separately numbered and often in Sir William's
4
Sir William Hooker.
set not numbered so that there is always the greatest uncertainty about the numbering and I once thought of not giving the numbers at all for fear of leading into error — sometimes also the numbers badly written have been misread and erroneously copied.
I am very steadily at work at the Flora.
5
Bentham (1863-78), vol. 4.
Since I wrote I have finished
Campanulaceae

Search for Campanulaceae in

(
Lobelia

Search for Lobelia in

18 sp.
Pratia

Search for Pratia in

6 sp.
Isotoma

Search for Isotoma in

6 sp.
Wahlenbergia

Search for Wahlenbergia in

2 sp.)
Scaevola

Search for Scaevola in

, 48 sp. and some small genera and nearly finished Goodenia. De Vriese's monograph is I agree with you the worst I ever met with and if I had not before me authentic specimens of the majority of his species I never could have made them out. In Hooker's collection which he had to work open he has given one name to five species belonging to three natural Orders. His generic characters sometimes belong to only a small portion of the species he puts under them. He quotes the same specimen for two different species — Describes one plant and figures another etc etc.
6
Vriese (1854). See M to G. Bentham, 21 April 1867 (in this edition as 67-04-21b).
There are only two or three of Brown's which appear not to be in your collection
7
R. Brown (1810), pp. 574-590.
Goodenia pumilio

Search for Goodenia pumilio in

a curious little plant which we have also from Cunningham and I do not think you have G. coronopifolia G. glabra Br. is G. flagellifera De Vr.
8
De Vriese.
G. viscidula
9
G. viscida?
Br is your G. spicata (at least for the look, I have not yet examined it)
I am afraid I shall have to make a genus
10
Bentham erected Catospermum (C. muelleri) in J. Hooker (1867-89), vol. 11, p. 20, t. 1028.
for your
Scaevola goodeniacea

Search for Scaevola goodeniacea in

, the ovary is so very exceptional there are 1 or 2 ovules in each cell pendulous from the apex of the cavity, whilst in all
Goodeniaceae

Search for Goodeniaceae in

I have as yet gone through they are erect I do not like monotypic genera and so I wait to decide till I have gone through all the little genera — If I find it really so exceptional I shall have it figured for Hooker's Icones which is now going on — the first part of the new Series is just out.
I am very glad to hear you have a collector in Arnhem's Land.
11
Benjamin Guilliver, who accompanied Francis Cadell's exploring expedition.
We want much good specimens of tropical and Central Australian plants to test the value of numerous species necessarily founded on single fragments.
Ever yours sincerely
George Bentham