Document information
Physical location:
A63/4772, unit 749, VPRS 1189/P inward registered correspondence, VA 475 Chief Secretary's Department, Public Record Office, Victoria. M63.07.13Preferred Citation:
residents of South Yarra, Toorak and Prahran to James McCuloch, 1863-07-13 [M63.07.13]. R.W. Home, Thomas A. Darragh, A.M. Lucas, Sara Maroske, D.M. Sinkora, J.H. Voigt and Monika Wells (eds), Correspondence of Ferdinand von Mueller, <https://vmcp.rbg.vic.gov.au/id//letters/mentions/selected/M63-07-13-final.odt>, accessed June 13, 2026
1
The Memorial is undated but is accompanied in the file by a covering letter dated
13 July 1863 from one of the signatories, T. Lightfoot, who had been entrusted with
the task of presenting it to the Chief Secretary. Lightfoot concluded his letter:
'I would beg to add, that I have used the road now shut up, for twelve years, and
that the one substituted will be impassible in the wet weather'.
To the Honorable
The Chief Secretary
of Victoria
The memorial of the residents in South Yarra, Toorak and Prahran and others whose
signatures are appended hereto, respectfully sheweth,
That your memorialists observe with regret that it is proposed to close the direct
thoroughfares leading from Park Street and Millswyn Street, South Yarra, by way of
the turnstile lately standing between the Museum and the Curators residence, through
the Botanical Reserves to Melbourne
That the thoroughfares referred to have for many years been used by your memorialists
and a large number of other persons, averaging at least one thousand daily, in preference
to any other route because they were considerably more direct and consequently shorter;
that the closing of them will necessarily cause a loss of time to each of the individuals
who habitually traverse them, while no apparent corresponding advantages can accrue
therefrom to any other persons or establishment.
That your memorialists are desirous that the paths in question should be properly
made, and planted on each side with ornamental trees, and your memorialists fully
believe that if this were done the paths would add a pleasing feature to the reserves,
they would afford all the accommodation which pedestrians require, and in so doing,
they would save the reserves from that disfigurement by unsightly tracks, which has
already resulted and may be expected to continue to result from leaving so large a
traffic either insufficiently or inappropriately provided for.
And your memorialists trust that you will accord to these views as herein set forth
your favorable consideration and influential support, and your memorialists as in
duty bound, will ever pray &c &c &c
2
The Memorial is followed by three pages of signatures with accompanying addresses,
74 signatures in all. On 14 July, McCulloch minuted: 'Acknowledge receipt and state
that enquiries will be made on the subject | Request Dr Mueller to wait on me'. The
next day, the Under Secretary, J. Moore, referred the document to M 'for report'.
For M's response, see M to J. McCulloch, 18 July 1863.