Document information
Physical location:
P79/4536, unit 153, VPRS 3991/P inward registered correspondence, VA 475 Chief Secretary's Department, Public Record Office, Victoria. 79.05.18Preferred Citation:
Ferdinand von Mueller to Bryan O'Loghlen, 1879-05-18. R.W. Home, Thomas A. Darragh, A.M. Lucas, Sara Maroske, D.M. Sinkora, J.H. Voigt and Monika Wells (eds), Correspondence of Ferdinand von Mueller, <https://vmcp.rbg.vic.gov.au/id//letters/1870-9/1879/79-05-18-final.odt>, accessed June 10, 2026
Melbourne
18/5/79.
To the honorable Sir Bryan O'Loghlen, Bt,
Acting Chief Secretary.
1
Sir
I have the honor to solicit, now while the estimates for the new finance-year are
under the consideration of the Government again, that you and your honorable Colleagues
will be pleased to give to the Report of the Committee of Dr L. Smith, Mr Bosisto
and the late Mr King, MLA,
your favorable consideration for the resuscitation of my Department in its proper
scope. The report of the above named Gentlemen, who were appointed by the hon Graham
Berry, to advise him respecting the means, required by me for the proper functions
of Gov. Botanist, was submitted long ago, but I have not sought to obtain an insight
into this document, being assured, that what the Committee recommended would be reasonable
and just. I believe however, that I shall be in consonance with the general views
of the Committee on my case, if I beg of you, to cede to me the buildings, now occupied
as temporary almhouses or immigrants homes at the City bridge, it being doubtless
the intention of the Government to remove early the paupers from the close vicinity
of Government House, on sanitary considerations.
I would further ask, in probable conformity of the Committee's recommendation, that
all the ground in Gov. House reserve, not enclosed for the private use of His Excellency
the Governor, be allotted to my control, from the boathouses up to the St Kilda Road
and towards the Barracks and the vicinity of the Observatory. It needs not my explanation,
that in a clime like ours a few acres would be utterly insufficient for my purposes,
as a full collection of different trees from all parts of the globe, so far as hardy
here, would occupy alone a very extensive area, not to speak of the numerous other
kinds of plants, which as Gov. Botanist I should have in a
living
state under my daily observation. Indeed I may be allowed to remark, that in every
other country the Gov. Botanist is provided with a botanic Garden; so it is with Sir
Jos. Hooker at Kew & everywhere else. The administration of the new grounds, asked
by me,
need not involve a heavy
annual expense
,
nor would my planting scheme be solely scientific but
ornamental
as well
. In the ground asked for, almost every tree has been raised by me, so that I would
return to a creation of my own, utterly neglected since; and by removing from me the
undeserved and deeply saddening
humiliation
, which also
impedes my work
in most directions, my hopes of life by your kindness would become once more brightened.
2
See L. Smith to G. Berry, 11 July 1877 (in this edition as M77-07-11).
3
M had made a similar request, some years previously, to have these buildings allocated
to him; see M to J. MacPherson, 26 June 1876, and M to G. Berry, 7 August 1877.
I have the honor to be,
Sir,
Your obed. serv.
Ferd. von Mueller
4
On Wednesday 4 June 1879 L. Smith wrote to B. O'Loghlen, Acting Chief Secretary: 'Dr
Mueller having written to me stating that you have granted him an interview on friday
but having omitted the hour will you please inform me the time you have appointed.
I will then bring up with me as Chairman the copy of the Report.' (P79/5117, unit
1086, VPRS 3991/P, PROV).
On 7 June 1879 O'Loghlen minuted: 'Will the Commissioner of Public Works be good enough
to direct some leading officer of his department to report on the buildings now occupied
as the Immigrants Home on the
Eastern
side of the St Kilda Road with a view to their suitability for a Botanical Museum
and the Government Botanists Residence'.
A week later, on 13 June, Charles Barrett, Chief Assistant Architect of the Public
Works Office, reported:
I have the honor to report that this establishment consists chiefly of six substantial
brick buildings in a fair state of repair fuller particulars of which are given on
the other side
The Hospital could be converted into a residence for the Government Botanist at a
cost of about £250.0.0. The conversion of the Dormitories, Mess Room &c into Botanical
Museums including repairs to Fencing and drainage is estimated to cost an additional
£225.0.0.
As I have not been furnished with particulars of the number of buildings it is proposed
to occupy as a Museum, or of the nature and extent of the Fittings, Furniture &c required
I am unable to estimate these latter but believe they would form a serious item in
the cost of the work.
The letter includes a sketch of the buildings and a brief description of each, with
dimensions. Barrett's report was forwarded to the Departments of the Chief Secretary
and Public Works.
On 18 June 1879, the day after the Chief Secretary, G. Berry, resumed office upon
returning from a visit to London, M wrote seeking an interview with him prior to the
Estimates being finally settled; see M to W. Odgers, 18 June 1879.
L. Smith wrote to Berry on 12 July 1879: 'As Chairman of the Commission re Baron Mueller
I am requested by my colleague Mr Bosisto & by Mr Dow to ask you to receive us as
a Deputation to place the Baron's case before you, will you please name day & hour'.
On 14 July W. Odgers, Under Secretary instructed: 'Ack & say that C.S. is fully acquainted
with all the particulars of the case and doubts if any good purpose wd be served by
the interview but if the Gentn [Gentlemen] as Members of Part [Parliament] particularly
desire to see him Mr B. will be happy to receive them at noon on Thursday' [i.e. 17
July] (P79/6404, unit 1086, VPRS 3991/P, PROV).
In the event, no action was taken on M's proposal.