Document information
Physical location:
D73/11843, unit 746, VPRS 3991/P inward registered correspondence, VA 475 Chief Secretary's Department, Public Record Office, Victoria. 73.09.07Preferred Citation:
Ferdinand von Mueller to James Francis, 1873-09-07. R.W. Home, Thomas A. Darragh, A.M. Lucas, Sara Maroske, D.M. Sinkora, J.H. Voigt and Monika Wells (eds), Correspondence of Ferdinand von Mueller, <https://vmcp.rbg.vic.gov.au/id//letters/1870-9/1873/73-09-07-final.odt>, accessed May 15, 2026
1
The Secretary for Agriculture, A. Wallis, had sought information about the origin
and extent of the public interest in the Library of the Botanic Garden. See also W.
Odgers to M, 4 September 1873.
Ferd. von Mueller
7/9/73.
2
The Under Secretary, W. Odgers, referred M's letter to the Minister of Agriculture,
J. Casey, on 12 September. On 16 September Casey minuted: 'Having perused these papers
I think the only proper course to pursue is to request the hon Chief Secretary to
direct that the books shall be at once returned to the place whence they were taken.
When the arrangt was made transfng the Govt Botanist to the Dept of the hon Chief
Sey no order was made with respect to the library and I respectfully submit that the
Govt Botanist acted wholly without authority in removing any of these books without
first asking the approval of either the hon Chief Secy or myself. I should be most
happy to allow the Govt Botanist the free use of the library as he is the free use
of the Herbarium The books can be safely and convently kept in the Quarters of the
Curator of the Bot Gardens & the Govt Botanist can obtain any of them from time to
time as he requires them. But I submit he should first be requested to return them,
whence he took them without authority.'
On 20 September Francis minuted: 'Is there any record of the arrangement made, as
alleged, with Mr Haines?' Odgers ordered that a search be made for any relevant papers.
A list of files was subsequently appended: M864 (see M to J. McCulloch, 21 January 1865), O6131 (see footnotes of J. Moore to M, 29 June 1866), N6240 (not found), and D1161 (see M to W. Odgers, 1 September 1873).
On 15 December Wallis wrote to Francis: 'The library of the Botanical Garden, which
was removed without permission by the govt Botanist, has not yet been restored to
this Department. Mr Casey directs me to state that he will be obliged to the Honble
The Chief Secretary, if he will order its replacement at his earliest convenience.'
(C73/16102, unit 746, VPRS 3991/P, Public Record Office, Victoria).
There is no record of Francis having taken any action, and it would appear that M
retained control of the books, most of which were in his house when he died.