Document information
Physical location:
No. 4009, unit 24, pp. 2-5, VPRS 1187/P outward correspondence, VA 475 Chief Secretary's Department, Public Record Office Victoria. 70.12.23Preferred Citation:
William Odgers to Ferdinand von Mueller, 1870-12-23. R.W. Home, Thomas A. Darragh, A.M. Lucas, Sara Maroske, D.M. Sinkora, J.H. Voigt and Monika Wells (eds), Correspondence of Ferdinand von Mueller, <https://vmcp.rbg.vic.gov.au/id/70-12-23>, accessed September 11, 2025
Chief Secretarys Office
Melbourne 23rd December 1870
Sir
I have the honor to inform you that your letter of the 22nd inst remonstrating against
the appointment of the Board referred to in my letter of the previous day
and more especially against the appointment of Mr Josiah Mitchell on the ground of
his having already exhibited a feeling of hostility to yourself has been laid before
the Chief Secretary
1
W. Odgers to M, 21 December 1870 (in this edition as 70-12-21a).
Sir James McCulloch directs me to say that he does not understand how you could suppose
that any humiliation is intended to yourself in the appointment of a Board to inquire
into the best means of re-organizing a Department that belongs to the State.
I am to point out that if your time and the scientific knowledge you possess have
been devoted to the administration of the Botanic Gardens you have also received a
liberal remuneration from the country for your services.
The Chief Secretary is at a loss to know what you intend to convey by stating that
you have sacrificed your private property in the interest of the State.
With respect to Mr Mitchell Sir James McCulloch recommended that he should be nominated
as one of the members of the Board in consequence of the high personal character he
has received of that gentleman coupled with his ability to bring practical experience
to bear on the questions proposed to be submitted for the consideration of the Board
2
In their letters accepting appointment as members of the Board of Inquiry, dated respectively 26 and 28 November, Hammill and Greig simply indicated their willingness
to serve. Mitchell, however, in his letter, also dated 28 November, clearly indicated his already set opinion: 'I may add that I the more readily agree at this busy season of the year
— hay harvest — to aid in the proposed inquiry from a strong conviction as to the
urgent necessity existing for some improvement in the organization & management of the department of
the Botanic Gardens'. By contrast, John Carson, who had also been approached, declined because of conflicts of interest:
I beg to state that I have long been intimate with Dr Von Mueller (who has often talked
to me of his position in the Gardens) as also with Mr Ferguson who's eldest Daughter
has for a considerable time been one of my Shop Assistants.
These circumstances I am of opinion should exclude me from this Board. Otherwise I
should have had great pleasure in doing what I must now most respectfully decline.
William Ferguson had been appointed as curator in November 1869, but he and M remained
at loggerheads.
(All letters at unit 473, VPRS 3991 inward registered correspondence, VA 475 Chief Secretary's Department,
Public Record Office, Victoria.)
I have the honor to be
Sir
Your most obedient servant
W. H. Odgers
The Director
Botanic Gardens